
Historic Homes For Sale in Sarasota
Ben Nathan provides luxury real estate representation to buyers and sellers of Historic homes across Sarasota. The architectural history in Sarasota is rich and diverse, with homes ranging from Mediterranean, bungalow, modern, and vernacular styles.
Historic Homes For Sale in Sarasota
Each home below is currently listed and carries a local or National historic designation, or has documented ties to a notable architect. This list is ranked by date added and reviewed regularly — last updated 09 Nov 2026. Want a custom search built around a specific architecture or district? Leave a message below, or reach out directly.
Sarasota's Architectural History
Sarasota's historic neighborhoods hold some of the city's most significant architecture. Mediterranean Revival estates fill Granada and Sapphire Shores. Meanwhile, bungalows define Laurel Park and Gillespie Park — both listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
Real estate agent Ben Nathan loves to research the architect, era, and preservation history behind every historic home he lists or shows. So buyers understand exactly what they're purchasing, and sellers can market their home's story, not just its square footage.
Maybe you're searching for a designated landmark. Maybe it's a restored 1920s bungalow, or a character home in one of Sarasota's protected districts. Either way, Ben brings years of experience with the city's architectural and historic housing. And if mid-century modern design is more your style, explore the Sarasota School of Architecture. That movement put this city on the international map.
Where to Find Historic Homes in Sarasota
Historic homes appear throughout Sarasota's established neighborhoods, not just inside official districts. Some of the richest concentrations surround the Ringling Museum, Cherokee Park, and McClellan Park. There, Mediterranean Revival and Mission-style homes from the 1920s still line the streets.
Lido Shores, on the other hand, holds one of the country's largest concentrations of Sarasota School of Architecture homes. Architects like Paul Rudolph and Ralph Twitchell built these modernist landmarks in the 1950s and 60s. Downtown, the Burns Court and Laurel Park districts preserve an earlier era of bungalows and cottages.
For a full breakdown of each district, its architectural styles, and what buying one involves, see our complete guide to Sarasota's historic districts and architecture.
Notable Historic Homes in Sarasota
These four homes capture Sarasota's most notable architectural styles. Mediterranean, modern, bungalow, and colonial homes are the styles most associated with the city's architectural history, so Ben picked one standout example of each. Their sale histories also reflect what historic homes command on today's market.

Casa del Carnevale — 139 S. Washington Drive, Saint Armands
Listed in 2026 for $12,950,000
Charles Leigh, co-founder of the Lavoris Chemical Company, built this Mediterranean-style estate in 1936. Leigh's daughter and son-in-law, a Ringling Museum curator and circus historian, later lived here. For example, a stained-glass entry awning and a 65-foot Roman-style pool still nod to those circus-world ties. The 7,800-square-foot waterfront estate is currently under contract for a listing price of $12,950,000.

The Revere Quality House — 100 Ogden Street, Siesta Key
SOLD in 2025 for $6.4 Million
Ralph Twitchell and his young associate Paul Rudolph designed this 1948 home to showcase Revere Copper and Brass products. In the process, they produced what many consider the first true expression of the Sarasota School of Architecture. In 2007, architect Guy Peterson restored the original house as a guest cottage and pool pavilion. He also built a new 4,755-square-foot companion residence in its spirit. The combined estate last sold in January 2025 for $6.4 million.

The Westermann House — 1716 Oak Street, Laurel Park
SOLD in 2023 for $1,500,000
This historic Sarasota home was not built where it stands today. In 1938, the Westermann family bought this lot on Oak Street and had the house moved there from its first site in Bahia Vista Highlands.
In June 2004, the house was sold, and the new owner began a careful expansion. She added an owner's suite, a garage, and a guest apartment, and planted an informal English garden with a gazebo. Working with architect Christopher Wenzel and the City of Sarasota Historic Preservation Board, she made sure each addition respected the home's original character and the historic look of the surrounding neighborhood. Ball Construction finished the work in January 2006, and the result is a home where modern comfort sits comfortably alongside its early 20th-century history.

The Early House — 1841 Oak Street, Laurel Park
SOLD in 2019 for $718,595
Judge John L. Early, a prominent Florida attorney who represented John Ringling, moved this wood-frame Colonial Revival cottage by barge to its Laurel Park lot in 1933. Ringling himself gifted the tiles that still line the home's fireplace hearth and front porch. The two-story cottage retains its original pine flooring and a stone fireplace built from Bradenton quarry stone. It last sold in May 2019 for $718,595 — modest next to Sarasota's grander landmarks, but rich with local history.
What to Know About Owning a Historic Home in Sarasota
Tax Benefits and Code Flexibility
Owning a historic home in Sarasota comes with real trade-offs, and most buyers find the benefits outweigh the complexities. Locally or nationally designated properties can qualify for a substantial Ad Valorem Tax Exemption on the cost of restoration work, and many are relieved from certain zoning setbacks and FEMA-related building code requirements that apply to newer construction.
The Certificate of Appropriateness
The trade-off is bureaucratic. Any exterior work on a designated property needs a Certificate of Appropriateness from the local and/or national Historic Preservation Board before you touch a window, a roofline, or even a coat of paint. That review protects the character that made the home valuable in the first place, though it does add a step most buyers of newer homes never encounter.
How Realtor Ben Nathan Helps
Ben walks every historic home buyer and seller through the real estate complexities. From what a designation status actually means to what a renovation will and won't require. For the full list of tax and preservation benefits, see our breakdown of historic designation in Sarasota.
Ready to Buy a Historic Home in Sarasota?
Schedule a consultation to discuss your search, or reach out for live updates on new listings.
Selling a historic homeinstead? Get a home Valuation
Frequently Asked Questions About Buying and Selling Historic Homes
Buying or selling a historic home in Sarasota raises questions that don't come up with typical resale properties — from what qualifies as “historic” to how a designation affects renovations, taxes, and resale value. Below are the questions I hear most often from buyers and sellers navigating this part of the market.
If you don't see your question here, reach out directly. Every historic property carries its own designation status and restrictions, and the details matter more than they do with a standard listing.
What makes a Home Historic?
A home generally qualifies as historic once it turns 50 years old, though it isn't formally considered historic until it is added to the Sarasota Register of Historic Places or the National Register of Historic Places
What Makes Buying a Historic Home Different?
Financing, inspections, and renovation planning all work a little differently. Lenders sometimes require specialized insurance or extra documentation for older systems, and any exterior renovation on a designated property needs approval from the city's Historic Preservation Board before work begins. I walk buyers through each of these steps up front, so there are no surprises after closing.
Can I find Historic Homes for sale outside Historic Districts?
Yes. Historic homes sit scattered throughout Sarasota and Manatee County, not just inside the city's official historic districts. A property can carry individual historic designation on its own, even on a street where none of its neighbors do.
Should I remove my Historic Designation before Selling a Home?
Usually not. Historic designation tends to add value, not subtract it, since it signals authenticity and passes the tax exemption and preservation benefits on to the next owner. Removing a designation is also a formal process through the city, not a simple checkbox, so I'd talk through your specific situation before recommending it either way.
Planning to buy or sell a Historic home?
Let’s get in touch


